What is a Share? Difference Between Two Types of Shares
Tags :
Class 12,Indian Economic Development,Liberalisation,Privatisation and Globalisation,UPSC Examination
Share This :
Difference Between Privatisation, Denationalisation, and Disinvestment
15/08/2025
Indian Economic Development,
Class 12,
Liberalisation, Privatisation and Globalisation
1. Privatisation: Shifting from Public Hands
Think of privatisation as moving a business out of government control. It means selling off all or part of a state-owned company – its ownership, management, and control – to private individuals or firms. Why do governments do this? Often, the goal is to boost efficiency and profits. Without constant political meddling, these businesses might innovate more and offer better service. Of course, there are downsides; sometimes jobs get cut or prices go up for consumers. A clear recent example is India’s national carrier, Air India, which transitioned back to the Tata Group in 2021. This move can happen entirely or just partially, using methods like direct sales or reducing the government’s stake (disinvestment).
2. Denationalisation: The Full Exit
Denationalisation is privatisation taken to its absolute conclusion. It’s when the government sells off every last share it owns in a company, making a complete and permanent exit. Once done, the state has zero ownership and absolutely no say in how the business is run. This clean break can attract serious private investment and ease the government’s financial burdens. However, selling off something entirely, especially if it’s seen as vital (like energy or steel), can spark public debate. Remember British Steel in the UK? That was fully denationalised decades ago. In India, if the government ever sold its entire stake in BPCL, that would be a classic case of denationalisation.
3. Disinvestment: Cashing in Shares
Disinvestment is more of a financial tactic than a complete change of ownership. It simply means the government sells off a portion of its shares in a public sector company. This could be a tiny slice (like 5% or 10%) or a larger chunk, but crucially, the government might still keep control. The main driver here is usually raising money – it’s a handy tool for managing the national budget. Selling a minority stake, such as the LIC IPO in 2022 or chunks of Coal India, brings in revenue without necessarily handing over the keys. While it might inject some private-sector discipline and improve things a bit, the company often remains fundamentally a public sector entity unless a majority stake is sold.
| Feature | Privatization | Denationalisation | Disinvestment |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ownership | Partially or fully to private | Fully to private | Partial (can be small % or large %) |
| Government Role | May retain some control or exit fully | Completely exits | May still retain control |
| Example (India) | Air India to Tata Group | (If 100% of BPCL is sold) | LIC IPO, Coal India stake sale |
| Scope | Broader — includes ownership + control | Subset of privatisation | Narrow — only stake reduction |
| Outcome | Efficiency, competition, better services | No government interference | Revenue generation, possible control retention |
Key Differences at a Glance:
- Ownership Shift: Privatisation changes ownership partially or fully private. Denationalisation means only private owners. Disinvestment just reduces the government's shareholding, possibly leaving it still in charge.
- Government Role: After privatisation, the government might keep a small stake or some influence. After denationalisation, it has none. After disinvestment, it often remains the main controlling shareholder.
- The Bigger Picture: Privatisation aims for broader operational changes. Denationalisation is the most definitive exit. Disinvestment is first and foremost a fiscal strategy.
Putting it Together: How They Relate
- Privatisation is the broad umbrella term. It covers any move away from full state control, whether partial or total. Denationalisation is actually a specific type of privatisation. It includes denationalisation (full exit) and sometimes strategic disinvestment.
- Denationalisation is the "all-in" version of privatisation. It means the government washes its hands completely of ownership and influence. It is complete privatisation.
- Disinvestment, however, is different. It's primarily about selling shares to raise funds. It can be a step towards privatisation (if enough shares are sold), but it doesn't have to be. Selling a small percentage, like in the LIC IPO, is disinvestment without privatisation. It is a financial tool, and not always equivalent to privatisation.
In Short:
Privatisation is the overarching idea of moving state assets into private hands. Within that, denationalisation describes the scenario where the government exits completely. Disinvestment, meanwhile, is a financial mechanism for selling shares; it leads to privatisation only if control is relinquished, otherwise, it’s just the government lightening its investment load.
Have Any Question?
Wish to enquire about our teaching pedagogy? Contact Us via Call or Email
- +91-9136-336-336
- contact@uniquelearning.in